Title: Federal Appeals Court Limits Private Lawsuits under Voting Rights Act, Raising Concerns
In a recent decision with potential repercussions on voting rights, the 8th Circuit Court of Appeals ruled that private individuals and groups, including the NAACP, cannot sue under Section 2 of the federal Voting Rights Act. The 2-1 decision made by a panel of judges stated that only the U.S. attorney general has the power to enforce this key section of the law.
The ruling, which contradicts decades of precedent, has sparked concerns about weakened protections under the landmark 1965 legislation. The majority argued that Section 2 does not contain the same explicit language as other federal laws, such as the 1964 Civil Rights Act, which allows private groups to file lawsuits.
The case originated from a lawsuit brought by the Arkansas State Conference NAACP and the Arkansas Public Policy Panel. Their case was dismissed by a lower judge who sided with the recent decision. Chief Judge Lavenski R. Smith, in a dissenting opinion, questioned the recent ruling, advocating for adherence to existing precedent that permits private lawsuits unless the Supreme Court or Congress decides otherwise.
Civil rights and voting rights advocates have criticized the decision, arguing that it undermines the protections that the Voting Rights Act was intended to provide. It remains uncertain whether the groups involved in the case will appeal the decision, but the ruling currently only applies to federal courts within the 8th Circuit.
Experts predict that the case will eventually reach the U.S. Supreme Court, especially considering that the issue of private lawsuits under the Voting Rights Act was raised in a 2021 opinion by Justice Neil Gorsuch. Given that the Justice Department has limited resources to pursue such cases, many challenges to enforce Section 2 are typically brought by private plaintiffs. Critics fear that if only the U.S. attorney general is allowed to file such cases, it could significantly reduce the number of challenges and make them more vulnerable to partisan politics.
Efforts to restore the protections of the Voting Rights Act have faced obstacles in Congress, with Republicans blocking attempts to strengthen the legislation. However, the Congressional Black Caucus has called for an appeal to the U.S. Supreme Court in hopes of obtaining a reaffirmation of citizens’ right to bring forward lawsuits under Section 2.
As election law experts emphasize the significance of private challenges to uphold the Voting Rights Act, the implications of this ruling will continue to resonate in the ongoing fight for fair and equal access to the ballot box.
“Zombie enthusiast. Subtly charming travel practitioner. Webaholic. Internet expert.”